Épreuve de lecture critique d'article scientifique des épreuves classantes nationales: pertinence de la correction


  • Maruani Annabel
  • Giraudeau Bruno
  • Alison Daniel
  • Bertrand Philippe
  • Bourlier Pascal
  • Fauchier Laurent
  • Valat Jean-Pierre
  • Lorette Gérard

type de document



In 2008 the national ranking examination (NRE) will include a test on critical reading of scientific articles. This decision has provoked controversy about whether reproducible correction is possible. The aim of our study was to assess the consistency of grading between this two-part test (critical analysis and summarizing, analyzed separately), and the more classic tests.

plus d'information